Final Results:
Narwhal with tattoo scroll
82 (28%)
Circus train car
51 (17%)
Angler fish
23 (7%)
Origami
79 (27%)
Chameleon
53 (18%)

That means that a whole lot of floss - 100 skeins of Anchor floss, to be precise, will be going to the contributor of the winning suggestion, Lissa!
To everyone who contributed suggestions, thank you for your creativity, awesomeness, and just plain weirdness. :) And to Tala, who devised this whole idea of a Reader's Choice pattern, to be drawn by her, especial thanks! Anybody else super-excited about next month's stichalong? I know I am! :)